Thursday, January 22, 2009

Topic For Discussion: Could Miles be Halliwax's son?

Could Miles be Halliwax's baby?

Episode 1 begins with Dr. Halliwax (aka Dr. Pierre Chang) getting out of bed to feed a bottle to his infant child.

The baby's name is never said... nor is it even stated whether the child is a boy or a girl. But who thinks the child could be Miles?

Let's discuss...


Rhea said...

I think you might be on to something. It would be one of those amazing, coincidental, totally makes sense, LOST connections.

I'd have never thought of it. Good one, Shannon!

Lula! said...

I read a theory on another blog today where folks are floating around the idea that Charlotte will wind up being that baby.

But Miles would seem the more likely candidate.

For that scene to be the opener of Season 5, you know there's very important stuff going down, as innocuous as it may seem at first. I need to go back and rewatch it again...

Shannon said...

I do think Charlotte was born on the island (Miles asks her why she wants to leave when she's spent so much time trying to get back to it)...

The baby in question may or may not be Miles... but I don't think the baby is Charlotte. I've watched the beginning of episode 1 again and IMO, the baby looks like it has Asian characteristics.

My theory is that the baby IS Miles. There's just something going on with that dude and his spiritual abilities...

Denise said...

I think the baby is Miles. The timing would be right. As to whether he was born on the island or not, I think he could have been. Just because babies can't be born now doesn't mean they couldn't before there before. Or he could have been born off the island and brought to the island after his birth.

I'm sure it's not Charlotte. Even though she was supposedly born on the island that baby looked nothing like Charlotte and her red hair.

Jaime said...

I was thinking the same thing while watching the season opener. I guess we'll have to wait and see!

Melissa said...

I agree. The theory about Miles being the baby makes way more sense. Charlotte had to be born on the island. Why is her nose bleeding? She is the only one being effected negatively(so far) by the time warping. Something's up with that.
Ya'll are way more intuitive than I am. That's why I love sussing with ya.

Heather said...

We're assuming here that the baby was their only child. I happen to think that Charlotte is the baby we saw. That was a very fair baby to have two Japanese(?) parents. I also just got the impression that it was a girl. I have to go back and watch that scene over again and see if there was anything that might have given me that idea.

So, what if the baby WASN'T their only child. His wife DID say that it was his turn to feed "the baby" didn't she?

Maybe they brought Miles to the island with them.

kara with a k said...

I do think that it is possible that Miles is Pierre Chang's baby. That's just a detail that is too important not to have significance (you could even hear the baby crying in the background of the video they showed at Comicon). I don't think the baby was fair enough to be Charlotte. She is very very fair, to me the baby looked like he had more Asian characteristics.
I read somewhere that they wrote the part of Miles Straum specifically for Ken Leung. They obviously have a plan there. I am just hoping that this is his connection to the island. It will be stinkin' awesome if it is.

Denise said...

Here's a new theory that a friend of mine emailed me about Charlotte. She and her mother think that Charlotte might be Miles mother. I really don't think so but has anyone else thought that?

Heather said...

Ok, I rewatched the scene and the baby isn't as fair as I thought. I think it could be Miles too.

Rhea said...

I don't see how Charlotte could be Miles' mother. That's too weird.

Rhea said...

Aha, after further reading, I just realized that Charlotte can speak Korean. hmmm...interesting coincidence.

KDLOST said...

I think they made a point of showing the baby's face... looks like a boy, dark hair... so Miles is a WONDERFUL theory to me! So curious about Charlotte though.

(p.s. hope y'all don't mind me butting in here... I am such a newcomer, have been doing the fuselage for awhile but it's not as much fun as y'all... are there any spoiler rules? Heheheh, I sound like such a trekkie.)

TattooedMinivanMom said...

That might make some sense.

And I think Charlotte definitely was born on the island.

The reason her nose is bleeding is cause if the past gets changed then she might not exist anymore in the future.

Anonymous said...


10604 movies of premium DVD status

We secure thousands of the hottest movies you've been waiting to supervise! And they're infrequently ready in Hi-Def!
These movies are playable on most viewing devices including iPod, PDA (HandHelds), PC, DVD & DivX players.
There are definitely no limits. Download as much as you require with incredibly gamy speeds. No additional software is required!
Only click on a tie, download a flick picture show and watch it on your favorite player.

[size=4][url=]Sign Up[/url] today and forget about buying or renting DVDs offline. [/size]


[url=][b]TOP 40 BEST Movies:[/b][/url]
Summer Love aka Dead Man's Bounty
September Dawn
New in Town aka Chilled In Miami
Owning Mahowny
Core, The
Pitch Black
Six Thugs
Modesty Blaise
Love Song for Bobby Long, A
Good Night, and Good Luck.
Point Break
Legend of Bagger Vance, The
Dead Mary
Night Shift
Green Mile, The
Quest for Camelot
Christmas Wish, The
Layer Cake
Hazing, The
Home Alone 3
American Pie 2
Red Mist aka Freakdog
Cat People
Meet Joe Black
Brother Bear
Imagine Me & You
Everybody Dies
Memoirs of a Geisha
Just My Luck
Morgue, The
Masked and Anonymous

Anonymous said...


10605 movies of lure DVD status

We have thousands of the hottest movies you've been waiting to supervise! And they're second nearby in Hi-Def!
These movies are playable on most viewing devices including iPod, PDA (HandHelds), PC, DVD & DivX players.
There are indubitably no limits. Download as much as you require with incredibly treble speeds. No additional software is required!
Simply click on a tie-up, download a flick picture show and superintend it on your favorite player.

[size=4][url=]Sign Up[/url] today and forget about buying or renting DVDs offline. [/size]


[url=][b]TOP 40 BEST Movies:[/b][/url]
Into the Blue
Darkman III: Die Darkman Die
Allan Quatermain and the Temple of Skulls
Hunt for Eagle One, The
Rawhead Rex
Librarian: Quest for the Spear, The
Romy and Michele's High School Reunion
Memphis Belle
Madea Goes to Jail
Pink Panther 2
Home Alone 4
Charlie Wilson's War
King Kong
Scooby-Doo and the Loch Ness Monster
10 Items or Less
Killer Movie
Being There
Big Trouble in Little China
Simple Plan, A
Life of David Gale, The
Kramer vs. Kramer
Day Without a Mexican, A
Joe the King
Dead Birds
Executive Decision
Nightmare on Elm Street, A
House of 9

Anonymous said...

[url=]alistor electric garage door openers[/url] i will keep updating and this is excellent forum

Anonymous said...

Happy New year! :)

Anonymous said...

I would only get the 450 anytime minutes plan which I'm guessing is the cheapest plan, if there is something cheaper let me know. I would want 1,500 text messages and obviously the unlimited data it comes with. Ive been searching but different sources tell me different things, some say $75 some say up to $95 a month. Does anyone ahve a plan similar to this for the iphone 3g that can help and say what their monthly bill looks like?

[url=]unlock iphone 3g[/url]